Beach Plum Resort Montauk, Montauk - Reviews, Rooms Options & Prices 2025

Book with us

Up to 10% cheaper

than on Booking.com

Key details

About the Resort

779 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

The Beach Plum Resort is a boutique, family-friendly accommodation located in Montauk, featuring classic cedar-shingle architecture amidst natural woodland. This seaside resort provides personalized touches that emphasize comfort and relaxation. With direct access to less crowded beaches, the resort offers an escape from the bustling downtown area while maintaining proximity to prominent attractions and local favorites.

Location

Situated near landmark attractions such as beaches and state parks, the resort offers easy access to Montauk’s vibrant holiday attractions. The surrounding area features a blend of natural beauty and local culture, providing guests with a quintessential East End getaway.

Rooms

The resort features studios, one and two-bedroom condos, and cottages equipped with individual touches of decor. Each unit includes amenities such as a full kitchen, air-conditioning, free Wi-Fi, and a fireplace. Certain units provide views of the harbor, enhancing the idyllic coastal experience.

Eat & Drink

Onsite dining options include meals focusing on seasonal produce, with unique dishes like poached eggs over pan-seared cod fishcake. Guests can taste local flavors at nearby eateries, while also enjoying barbecue grills at the resort for outdoor dining.

Leisure & Business

The Beach Plum Resort provides a heated pool, picnic areas, and free yoga and fitness classes during the summer season. Guests can also explore recreational options like boat hire and mini golf available nearby.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Two-Bedroom Cottage

Max:

6 persons

60 m²

Bed options:

1 King Size Bed

Shower

Heating

room details

Check Prices

One-Bedroom Bungalow

Max:

2 persons

Bed options:

1 King Size Bed

room details

Check Prices

Cottage

Max:

2 persons

Bed options:

1 King Size Bed

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

Explore available ways to reach your dream destination

City Center

Montauk2300 ft

Airports

Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 66.1 mi

Tweed-New Haven (HVN) 103.7 mi

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Cozy Comfortable Stay

“The room was beautifully decorated and incredibly clean, making it feel like a home away from home.” view full review

Refreshing Shower

“The pressure in the shower was excellent, offering a rejuvenating experience after a long day.” view full review

Inviting Atmosphere

“The living area was spacious and comfortable, perfect for relaxing with friends after a day at the beach.” view full review

Fully Equipped Kitchen

“The kitchen was well-equipped, allowing us to prepare our meals easily and enjoy dining in.” view full review

General

Non-smoking rooms
Wi-Fi
Free parking
No pets allowed
Private beach

Sports & Fitness

Golf course

Guest Parking

Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

Services

Housekeeping

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Heated swimming pool
Beach access
Sun loungers
Garden area
BBQ facilities

Room features

Air conditioning
Sitting area
Patio
Terrace

Self-catering

Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

Media

Flat-screen TV

Room decor

Parquet floor

Location

779 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

Map view

779 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

City landmarks

Parks

Kirk Park Beach

4600 ft

Parks

Camp Hero State Park

5300 ft

67 South Essex Street

Saint Therese of Lisieux Church

4700 ft

Parks

Fort Pond Bay Park

1.7 mi

Store

Sunset Surf Shack

4400 ft

Parks

Shadmoor State Park

1.7 mi

50 S Fairview Ave

Montauk Downs State Park

1.8 mi

Golf Course

Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course

1.8 mi

Parks

Hither Woods Preserve

1.9 mi

Farm

Rita's Stable

2.0 mi

Hither Hills

2.2 mi

Fort Pond Bay

2.2 mi

18 Ditch Plains Rd

Ditch Plains Beach

2.3 mi

Parks

Theodore Roosevelt County Park

2.6 mi

Hither Hills West Overlook

2.9 mi

W Lake Dr

Gosman's Dock

3.3 mi

Nearby

Museums

Second House Museum

1300 ft

Montauk

Lake Montauk

1000 ft

Restaurants

ALL DAY at Breakers

200 ft

769 Old Montauk Hwy

Surfside Inn

2100 ft

685 Old Montauk Hwy

Bex Waffles

2600 ft

650 Montauk Hwy

7-Eleven

4000 ft

653 Montauk Hwy

Harvest On Fort Pond

5100 ft

11 South Emery Street

Sel Rrose

3300 ft

4 S Elmwood Ave

Zum Schneider Montauk

3300 ft

4 South Elmwood Avenue

The Point

4900 ft

697 Montauk Hwy

The Point Bar & Grill

4800 ft

697 Montauk Hwy

Pizza Village

5200 ft

700 Montauk Hwy

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience

84%

liked the resort and would come back again

8.4/10

Great

Rooms

7.6

Location

9.8

Service

8.0

Dining

5.0

Lauren

United States of America, February 2025

9.0/10

The Beach Plum Resort offers a charming location with lovely, clean accommodations right across from a beautiful beach. Our stay was filled with enjoyment, thanks to the friendly atmosphere and the well-maintained grounds. The kitchenettes are a fantastic bonus for families, although some rooms could use a little updating. The proximity to town for dining and activities is excellent, making it convenient for guests.

Rooms

8.0

Our room was cozy and clean, resembling a tiny beach house with all the kitchen supplies we needed for our stay. The decor was bright and refreshing, creating a warm atmosphere.

Service

9.0

The staff was incredibly helpful and made our check-in process seamless, allowing us to drop off our bags and enjoy the beach while we waited for our room.

Location

10.0

The resort is perfectly situated right across from the beach and just a short walk into the quaint town, providing easy access to everything Montauk has to offer.

Dining

Facilities

9.0

The grounds are well-maintained, featuring a gorgeous pool, picnic tables, and outdoor showers. It's great for families with kids who want to play outside.

Joseph

United States of America, January 2025

7.0/10

My stay at Beach Plum had its ups and downs. The location is excellent, within walking distance to the beach and town, making it convenient for getting around. The staff were friendly and accommodating, which I appreciated. Unfortunately, the beds were extremely uncomfortable, and the noise level was high, which affected our overall comfort. Improving these aspects would definitely enhance the experience.

Rooms

5.0

The rooms were clean, but the beds were uncomfortably hard. It was disappointing, especially when we were hoping for a restful night.

Service

8.0

The staff were friendly and worked hard to assist us, which made our stay more pleasant.

Location

9.0

The location is fantastic, just a short walk to the beach and the town center, allowing for easy exploration.

Dining

Facilities

6.0

The kitchenette was a great touch, and having a barbecue outside was an added bonus, though the pool area could use some maintenance.

United States of America, January 2025

8.6/10

I had a wonderful stay at the Beach Plum. The location is superb, just across the street from the beach, making it so convenient for our family. The room was comfortable and clean, fitting our needs well. However, we did face a couple of issues: our arrival was delayed by uninvited guests in our unit, and the sheets had some wear and tear. Overall, I would recommend it for a pleasant getaway!

Rooms

8.0

The room was very inviting with a nautical theme, clean and comfortable. However, we noticed some torn sheets which could use attention.

Service

7.0

The service was generally good, though we experienced a check-in issue with unexpected guests in our unit.

Location

10.0

The Beach Plum is perfectly situated, just a short walk to the beach and town, offering great views and access to amazing beaches.

Dining

Facilities

9.0

The facilities were well-maintained, and the cottage we stayed in was spacious with a good layout for our family.

Jeremiah

United States of America, December 2024

8.6/10

My friends and I had an amazing long weekend at the Beach Plum! Our cottage was a delightful surprise, decorated with a charming beach theme. The resort is just across the street from the beach, which is super convenient, and it's within walking distance to town. While we loved the beach access, the only downside was some issues with our bedding that could be improved. Overall, it offered great value and an authentic Montauk vibe.

Rooms

9.0

We stayed in a cute cottage that was small yet perfect for our group. The beach-themed decor added such a nice touch, and everything felt very clean and inviting.

Service

7.0

The staff was really helpful during our stay. They were responsive when we asked for extra bedding, although it took a couple of reminders to get it.

Location

10.0

The location can’t be beat! Being so close to the beach made our mornings so much better, and it was a nice, short walk to the grocery store in town.

Dining

Facilities

8.0

We enjoyed the clean pool area, complete with a pool house for towels and showers, which added convenience to our beach days.

James

United States of America, December 2024

8.8/10

I had a lovely stay at this resort with a perfect location, just steps away from the beach and a short walk to the town. The room was clean with a charming deck that offered great views, making it a great spot for my annual girls' trip. However, not all rooms seem equally cared for, and some furnishings were outdated, which impacted the overall experience. Despite this, the price was reasonable, and the amenities, including the pool, were enjoyable.

Rooms

8.0

We stayed in a clean room with updated features, but some units might need an overhaul as they felt dated.

Service

9.0

The staff was very focused on ensuring we had fun during our stay.

Location

10.0

The location was fantastic, a 10-minute walk to town and just 2 minutes to the beach.

Dining

Facilities

8.0